• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Friends of Kananaskis Country

Enhance, protect and share the unique natural and cultural experiences of Kananaskis Country through public participation and environmental education.

Header Right

Donate Join Us Volunteer-Events Calendar
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Vision and Mission
    • The Team
    • The Advisory Council
    • Thanks Volunteers
  • About K-Country
    • Kananaskis Country
    • Trail Maps
    • Trail Reports
    • Bite-Sized Advice
    • Trail & Camping Info
    • Kananaskis Conservation Pass
    • Critters of K-Country
    • Flowers of K-Country
    • Plants of K-Country
    • Fungi of K-Country
  • Programs + Events
    • Trail Care
      • Recruiting Crew Leaders & Backcountry Crew
      • Migratory Birds and the Friends
    • Canmore Trail Alliance
    • Trails Fest
    • Environmental Education
    • Chandra Crawford Hut at CNC
  • Engage
    • Sign Up and Join Us
    • Volunteer
      • Volunteer Projects
    • Trail Day – What to Bring & Expect
    • Volunteer Agreement, Release and Waiver of Liability Form
    • Corporate Trail Building Days
    • Trail Groups and Clubs
  • Library
    • Latest News
    • Annual Reports
    • Great Kananaskis Flood Book
    • Bylaws & Cooperating Agreement
    • Newsletter
      • 2020 Newsletter Archive
      • 2019 Newsletter Archive
      • 2018 Newsletter Archive
      • 2017 Newsletter Archive
      • 2016 Newsletter Archive
      • 2015 Newsletter Archive
      • 2014 Newsletter Archive
      • 2013 Newsletter Archive
      • 2012 Newsletter Archive
      • 1997 – 2008 Newsletter Archive
    • Policies
  • Support
    • Donate
    • Legacy Fund
      • Legacy Fund FAQs
    • Planned Giving
    • Trail Love Give Back
    • SkipTheDepot
    • Our Supporters
    • Thanks
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Vision and Mission
    • The Team
    • The Advisory Council
    • Thanks Volunteers
  • About K-Country
    • Kananaskis Country
    • Trail Maps
    • Trail Reports
    • Bite-Sized Advice
    • Trail & Camping Info
    • Kananaskis Conservation Pass
    • Critters of K-Country
    • Flowers of K-Country
    • Plants of K-Country
    • Fungi of K-Country
  • Programs + Events
    • Trail Care
      • Recruiting Crew Leaders & Backcountry Crew
      • Migratory Birds and the Friends
    • Canmore Trail Alliance
    • Trails Fest
    • Environmental Education
    • Chandra Crawford Hut at CNC
  • Engage
    • Sign Up and Join Us
    • Volunteer
      • Volunteer Projects
    • Trail Day – What to Bring & Expect
    • Volunteer Agreement, Release and Waiver of Liability Form
    • Corporate Trail Building Days
    • Trail Groups and Clubs
  • Library
    • Latest News
    • Annual Reports
    • Great Kananaskis Flood Book
    • Bylaws & Cooperating Agreement
    • Newsletter
      • 2020 Newsletter Archive
      • 2019 Newsletter Archive
      • 2018 Newsletter Archive
      • 2017 Newsletter Archive
      • 2016 Newsletter Archive
      • 2015 Newsletter Archive
      • 2014 Newsletter Archive
      • 2013 Newsletter Archive
      • 2012 Newsletter Archive
      • 1997 – 2008 Newsletter Archive
    • Policies
  • Support
    • Donate
    • Legacy Fund
      • Legacy Fund FAQs
    • Planned Giving
    • Trail Love Give Back
    • SkipTheDepot
    • Our Supporters
    • Thanks
  • Contact

Naismith’s Rule

“Are we there yet?”

Good planning promotes good ethics and safety in the outdoors. Knowing how long you’re expecting to be out is part of good hike planning. But we know many folks who under- and over estimate the amount of time needed for a day’s outing. There’s a way that you can better estimate it, and perhaps give an answer when your kids ask “How much farther is it, mom?”

The Naismith Rule

William Naismith was a Scottish mountaineer and guide who developed a time estimating methodology for wandering around the Scottish hills way back in 1892. We first learned about it in the preface to the Second Edition of Gillian Daffern’s Kananaskis Country Trail Guide in 1985. The original Naismith Rule is pretty simple:

For adults, plan on 5 km/hr, plus 30 min for every 300 m of height gain.

Many have offered “upgrades” to the formula. Gillean suggested a formula for youth groups of 4.5 km/hr plus 1 hr for every 450 m climb. There’s something called the “Tranter correction” to the original formula which adjusts for fatigue. There are corrections for gentle or severe slopes. A check on Wikipedia under “Naismith’s Rule” will show you these correction options and more, like the “Aitkin-Langmuir Correction”, “Scarf’s Equivalence” and the “Tobler Hiking Function”. Tobler’s came in a paper called “Non-isotropic modelling speculations on the geometry of geography global spatial analysis“. We would say it’s worth a read, but only if you have a Ph.D.

Does it work for real?

Having engineering in our professions here at the Friends, we have been tracking hikes, and comparing times to Mr. Naismith’s for years. We don’t “correct” times by taking out times for lunches, or for other breaks along the trail.

Our conclusion is Mr.’s Aitkin, Langmuir, Tobler, Scarf and Tranter need to get a better life and just go hiking more. We don’t think any adjustment to Mr. Naismith’s simple rule is needed for general planning purposes.

In the 124 hikes plotted above, Naismith’s rule is 81% accurate in predicting times. Being closet statisticians, we can also tell you that Naismith’s rule will accurately predict hiking time within 8.8%, in 19 hikes out of 20.

What Naismith doesn’t tell you

A more advanced statistician will tell you that Naismith’s 2 factors – distance and height gain – explain 68% of the amount of time a hike will take. Other factors are at play. As a result, we have looked at the “outliers” in the above data (like where Naismith would say it should take 6:50, but it only took 2:50). All are explained by things like the use of bikes for part of the hike, the presence of pikas, moose or other wildlife that we stood around and watched, or other factor that made the day not a “normal” hike. Obviously, statisticians are right (as usual), but 68% is good enough for us.

The best part is that you, too, can start collecting your own data and planning your day to compare. If you find Naismith’s rule doesn’t work perfectly for you, it’s easy to adjust. Plus, by using a good guidebook and a map when you’re on the trail, you can give a good answer to the question that every parent dreads:

“Are we there yet?”

How about other sports?

We have searched, and collected our own data. We have tried. At this point, we cannot offer a predictive tool that will help you plan your mountain bike, XC ski, snowshoe or paddling adventures. We’re happy to share any you have.

Learn more about planning your K-Country adventures here!

Footer

Contact Us

email: info@kananaskis.org
Phone: 403.678.5593
Mail Address:
Suite 201, 800 Railway Ave.
Canmore, Alberta
T1W 1P1

You can also find us on

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS
  • Twitter
Donate Join Us Volunteer Calendar

Site Footer

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2023 · developed by Artmann Comm on Genesis Framework